[ { "dimension_id": "A1", "dimension_name": "问题重要性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 85, "population_variance": 0, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 85, "B": 85, "C": 85, "D": 85, "E": 85 } }, { "dimension_id": "A2", "dimension_name": "原创性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 5, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 71, "population_variance": 4, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 70, "C": 70, "D": 70, "E": 75 } }, { "dimension_id": "A3", "dimension_name": "实质推进程度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 4, "n_tentative": 1, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 74, "population_variance": 4, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 75, "B": 75, "C": 75, "D": 70, "E": 75 } }, { "dimension_id": "A4", "dimension_name": "知识与解释增量", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 65, "population_variance": 0, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 65, "B": 65, "C": 65, "D": 65, "E": 65 } }, { "dimension_id": "B1", "dimension_name": "问题定义与评价有效性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 63, "population_variance": 6, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 65, "B": 65, "C": 60, "D": 60, "E": 65 } }, { "dimension_id": "B2", "dimension_name": "技术与论证正确性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 4, "n_tentative": 1, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 66, "population_variance": 4, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 65, "B": 65, "C": 65, "D": 65, "E": 70 } }, { "dimension_id": "B3", "dimension_name": "数据与评测流程完整性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 1, "n_tentative": 4, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 53, "population_variance": 16, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 55, "B": 55, "C": 45, "D": 55, "E": 55 } }, { "dimension_id": "B4", "dimension_name": "比较对象与比较公平性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 4, "n_tentative": 1, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 69, "population_variance": 14, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 70, "C": 65, "D": 65, "E": 75 } }, { "dimension_id": "C1", "dimension_name": "核心主张的证据充分度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 68, "population_variance": 6, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 65, "C": 70, "D": 65, "E": 70 } }, { "dimension_id": "C2", "dimension_name": "机制归因与竞争解释区分度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 73, "population_variance": 6, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 75, "B": 70, "C": 75, "D": 75, "E": 70 } }, { "dimension_id": "C3", "dimension_name": "结果稳定性与不确定性处理", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 37, "population_variance": 16, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 40, "B": 40, "C": 30, "D": 35, "E": 40 } }, { "dimension_id": "C4", "dimension_name": "适用范围与边界验证", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 68, "population_variance": 6, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 65, "C": 70, "D": 65, "E": 70 } }, { "dimension_id": "D1", "dimension_name": "过程透明度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 57, "population_variance": 16, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 60, "B": 60, "C": 50, "D": 55, "E": 60 } }, { "dimension_id": "D2", "dimension_name": "研究资源可获得性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 5, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 68, "population_variance": 16, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 75, "C": 65, "D": 65, "E": 65 } }, { "dimension_id": "D3", "dimension_name": "主张克制与报告一致性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 59, "population_variance": 14, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 60, "B": 55, "C": 55, "D": 65, "E": 60 } }, { "dimension_id": "D4", "dimension_name": "表达清晰度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 75, "population_variance": 0, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 75, "B": 75, "C": 75, "D": 75, "E": 75 } }, { "dimension_id": "E1", "dimension_name": "复杂度合理性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 64, "population_variance": 14, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 70, "B": 65, "C": 60, "D": 60, "E": 65 } }, { "dimension_id": "E2", "dimension_name": "资源效率与成本收益", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 1, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 1, "n_unknown": 4, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 50, "population_variance": 0, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": null, "B": null, "C": null, "D": null, "E": 50 } }, { "dimension_id": "E3", "dimension_name": "可迁移与可复用程度", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 72, "population_variance": 6, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 75, "B": 70, "C": 70, "D": 70, "E": 75 } }, { "dimension_id": "E4", "dimension_name": "后续研究启发性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 5, "n_rated": 5, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 0, "n_NA": 0, "mean": 80, "population_variance": 10, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": 75, "B": 85, "C": 80, "D": 80, "E": 80 } }, { "dimension_id": "F1", "dimension_name": "与当前问题的相关性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 0, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 5, "n_NA": 0, "mean": null, "population_variance": null, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": null, "B": null, "C": null, "D": null, "E": null } }, { "dimension_id": "F2", "dimension_name": "相对于已有知识的学习收益", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 0, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 5, "n_NA": 0, "mean": null, "population_variance": null, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": null, "B": null, "C": null, "D": null, "E": null } }, { "dimension_id": "F3", "dimension_name": "当前使用可行性", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 0, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 5, "n_NA": 0, "mean": null, "population_variance": null, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": null, "B": null, "C": null, "D": null, "E": null } }, { "dimension_id": "F4", "dimension_name": "当前决策信息价值", "reviewer_slots": 5, "n_numeric": 0, "n_rated": 0, "n_tentative": 0, "n_unknown": 5, "n_NA": 0, "mean": null, "population_variance": null, "scores_by_reviewer": { "A": null, "B": null, "C": null, "D": null, "E": null } } ]